15 Best Eyebrow Pencil – Shape It And Fill It!

Every girl wants those perfectly shaped eyebrows, don’t they? Nothing too thick or nothing too thin, we all want to have those Instagram perfect eyebrows, perfectly filled in to make it look natural. The best eyebrow pencil can completely transform the overall makeup results by sprucing up the look like no other.

With so many skin types and so many hair colors, chances are that not every eyebrow pencil you come across is going to tick off all your needs. But, that doesn’t mean you don’t have one that would suit your needs.

To help you pick the best pencil for eyebrows, we are going to list out some of the best available ones that you can take a peek into.

Best Rated Eyebrow Pencil Of 2019

When it comes round to picking a good eyebrow pencil, it is best to invest your time in assessing multiple aspects – right from the shade as well as the formula of the pencil.

If you have an oily skin, it is important that you find matte one that won’t move around after application and rather stay. It isn’t as easy as it might seem.

To help you pick the best eyebrow pencil, we have sorted out some of the best ones.

1. Maybelline New York Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil

What color eyebrow pencil for black hair? This is something that many women have in their minds. And, this isn’t just with black hair but with any hair type.

If you want a budget friendly good eyebrow pencil that comes in varying shades, the Maybelline New York Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil is one of the best options.

Review

With this eyebrow pencil, not only can you fill in your eyebrows, you can effectively shape them with the spoolie brush it comes with. The best part about this specific product is the fact that it is a drugstore brand so you don’t have to pay a hefty amount for a pencil to carve your eyebrows out.

It comes in varying shades to match almost every hair type and skin tone that one has which is yet another one of the added bonus. It also has a very skinny tip which further ensures that you get precision with your eyebrows.

2. Tom Ford Brow Sculptor

Before anyone starts a screaming match, let me say that the Tom Ford Brow Sculptor is a good product even with the kind of price point it comes along with.

Review

More than a sculptor, this helps in filling the eyebrows out. If you have been questioning what color eyebrow pencil for dark brown hair, this is the perfect one for that. It does have an angled applicator which allows you to get the perfect strokes with ease.

If you like your eyebrows to have a very natural finish without making it seem like you did something, this is your buddy. Another thing that makes it a good option is because it stays on for a long time.

3. Nyx Professional Makeup 3-In-1 Brow

When it comes round to the best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows, the Nyx Professional Makeup 3-In-1 Brow is one of the best one around.

Review

The primary reason why majority of the women recommend this as one of the best eyebrow pencil is because of the kind of pigmentation it has. This ensures that you won’t have to go over and over again with the application of the product. A little does go a long way.

The best part of this product is the fact that it is 3-in-1. What it means that you have your standard eyebrow pencil, the gel to set things in place and even the corrector that helps carve out the eyebrows for a precise looking brow.

4. Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil

You can never talk about eyebrow pencils and not talk about the Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil, that is not how it works.

Review

The main reason why this eyebrow pencil is considered one of the best is because of the amazing angled tip that it has. It makes it easier for you to draw strokes without making them seem very artificial or drawn upon which is nothing but an added bonus. The matte and powdery consistency further makes it an amazing option if you don’t have very good and dense eyebrows.

The addition of the spoolie brush is what takes it up by a notch. It is well carved and ensures to get your eyebrow in place without causing much of a ruckus. You can easily blur out the pigment with the brush if you have put in a lot.

5. ALMAY Brow Pencil

If you have been trying to find what color eyebrow pencil for black hair, the ALMAY Brow Pencil can get the job done.

Review

Apart from the fact that it is a drugstore brand and you are getting the best of both worlds with the additional spoolie brush too, you are in for a ride with this one. It does come in two colors, best suited for two different eyebrow color.

It is amazing for people with deeper and darker skin tones, so if you are from either, this can actually prove out to be a boon for you unknowingly. If you just want to fill in the eyebrows, this is a good option as it is quite opaque as well.

6. L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Stylist Definer Brow Liner

If you are on the lookout for yet another one of the drugstore brand that won’t dig a hole in your pocket, the L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Stylist Definer Brow Liner is one of the best options to look into.

Review

The main reason why this specific eyebrow pencil is considered as one of the best ones around is because of the fact that it comes for almost every single type of eyebrow hair color, from the browns to the black and blondes. Additionally, it is dual ended brush with a pencil on one end and a brush on the other, thus further making it easier for the users.

Buying just one of these eyebrow pencils will tentatively last you for 2-3 months of regular usage. The main reason why it is so is because of the high pigmentation and a little goes a long way. The product also comes in a very smooth texture, which further helps in bringing forth better results for shaping your eyebrows.

7. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

When it comes to the best eyebrow pencil that caters to every eyebrow shade, the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz has its quality packed full and well.

Review

The most important factor about this eyebrow pencil is the fact that it comes in 10 different colors. Each one of them has been specifically modified to ensure the best match for your eyebrows. Much like the majority of the available eyebrow pencils in the market, this one comes with a thin pencil and a spoolie brush.

The brush produces very thin and very smoothly sculpted strokes for your hair like no other. It is said to create hyperreal strokes which itself is very intimidating to think about. The color and the matches and even the pigmentation of the pencil is so amazing that it doesn’t look like you have drawn the hair on.

8. Milk Makeup Gel Brow

Milk makeup has established their position in the market with the amazing range of products and the Milk Makeup Gel Brow is no exception to that.

Review

The primary reason why this is considered as the best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows and even for oily skin is because of the fact that it is formulated to last you through the time. It is a bit costly than the standard amount you’d want to spend on an eyebrow pencil but the investment is worth it in the end.

The main reason why this is an amazing product is because of the fact that it has a water-proof as well as smudge proof formula as well. The fine tip ensures smooth application as well, which is yet another bonus because then you don’t have to drag the product out much.

9. Ofra Cosmetics Universal Eyebrow Pencil

Even though it does make claims to be a universal eyebrow pencil, Ofra Cosmetics Universal Eyebrow Pencil is the best answer for what color Eyebrow pencil for dark brown hair.

Review

Many people have this thought that the universal eyebrow pencil gets everything done for you but that isn’t the case, for the most part. Yes, it is a good product and it gets the job done but it wouldn’t necessarily work on someone with blonde eyebrows. That is straight-up a lie.

The good thing about this eyebrow pencil is the fact that it has a very waxy finish to it which proves amazing in keeping your eyebrows in place. It works along with the shape of your own eyebrows, which is again an added bonus.

10. Glossier Boy Brow

The Glossier Boy Brow is yet another one of the masterpieces when it comes round to the best pencil for eyebrows.

Review

More than the overall prospect of the pencil, this is an addition to perfectly finish off the eyebrow that you have carved out. The main reason why this is regarded as the best one to set your eyebrows is because of the fact that it brings forth an amazing range of density and realness to the eyebrows.

The pigmentation is amazing and just perfect for you to get those beautiful strokes that resemble natural hair. It helps add dimension to the eyebrows to ensure that the hairs look in place and well filled out.

11. Rimmel Professional Eyebrow Pencil

Rimmel Professional has time and time provided with some of the best products and the Rimmel Professional Eyebrow Pencil is no different.

Review

If you want an eyebrow pencil that is waxy and will help fill in the gaps in the between, this is actually an amazing option because of how perfectly pigmented it is. It doesn’t make you look over the top but adds in the much needed fill and color that you need for those perfectly sculpted eyebrows without any further questions.

It is perfect for the women who have darker eyebrows, because of the shade range that they come with. So, if you are blonde, chances are that there isn’t much option to work within this. It is best suggested to ensure that you do focus on application and don’t overdo it because a little does go a long way.

12. Rodial Microblade Effect Eyebrow Pencil

If you have been on the lookout for the best eyebrow pencil in a budget that won’t end up digging a hole in your pocket, the Rodial Microblade Effect Eyebrow Pencil is one of the best options around.

Review

Much like any other standard and good eyebrow pencil, this one does live up to the standards for the minimal price that you are paying for it. It is quite lightweight and compact, thus ensuring that you can carry it around while travelling as well without any kind of issues at all.

It is also quite well pointed which ensures that you don’t have to worry about the deep smudges, instead get microblading like finish on your eyebrows which is pretty amazing. Another amazing thing that makes this the best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows is the fact that it is available in multiple and varying shades for every eyebrow hair type.

13. Elf Cosmetics Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil

Cheap but the quality is what the Elf Cosmetics Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil redefines mainly because of the amazing quality and the shape that it has been designed with.

Review

For the most part, the primary reason why women do opt for the Elf Cosmetics Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil is because of the price point it comes with. At just $1.99, you can’t get anything better than that. The only issue with this is the fact that it does come in only three shades, so it’s not universal.

If you have been on the lookout for what color eyebrow pencil for silver hair, chances are that this won’t fit the bill well because of the lack of the shade range it comes with. Other than that, you don’t necessarily have to worry about anything at all. All the shades are buildable as well which further makes it a good option to look into.

14. Too Faced Chocolate Brow-nie Cocoa Powder Brow Pencil

To answer what is the best eyebrow pencil for dark brown and brown shaded eyebrows, the Too Faced Chocolate Brow-nie Cocoa Powder Brow Pencil is one of the best options to look into.

Review

The primary reason why it works is because of the fact that it takes your eyebrow game to the next level without any kind of compromise at all. For those people looking for the best eyebrow pencil for oily skin, this is actually one of the best options that one can look into. It has a waterproof base to it that you just can’t compete with.

Additionally, it does have infused cocoa powder in it which further makes it a worthy option for all those ladies with brown and brownish eyebrows. It has a very precise and well angled applicator which further makes it easier for you to get those fine strokes that look natural and not too fake. To top it off, it has a subtle chocolate flavour to it.

15. Frame Your Face Micro Brow Pencil by Wander Beauty

Yet another one of the best pencil for eyebrows definitely has to be the Frame Your Face Micro Brow Pencil by Wander Beauty.

Review

For the most part, the Frame Your Face Micro Brow Pencil is formulated to cater to almost all the eyebrow color which is pretty amazing. This ensures that you can manage with it whatever shade of eyebrow hair you have. It also has a very fine and well maintained tip which ensures that the strokes are fine and not too smudgy.

It is perfect for the short strokes that you do to fill in the eyebrows without any issues at all. Additionally, it comes along with a spoolie brush which is most definitely an added bonus and helps in keeping your eyebrows well in shape and filled.

How to Choose Best Eyebrow Pencil?

When it comes round to the best eyebrow pencil for your misshaped eyebrows, you need to be very careful with the selection process.

Much like every other makeup product, even for the eyebrow pencils, it is not going to be universal. Not every shade or product will suit you which are why it is important that you take the time out to first assess the product that matches your shade and then go forth with the purchase.

Some of the important factors that you need to keep in mind include:

1. Before making the final decision for the purchase, it is very important to ensure that you do look out for the shade range. You just can’t forego that and pick out a universal shade. For the most part, that doesn’t work and might make you look funny with the mismatched shade. Take your time with picking the shade based on the kind of eyebrow hair color you have.
2. Look for a finer tip if you are willing to draw out your overall eyebrows and sculpt them from scratch because that helps maintain a better shape of the eyebrows without any question. Additionally, if you are looking for a top rate eyebrow pencil to just fill out the eyebrow, choose one accordingly. Waxy pencils work better in that case.
3. Check the price point too. While buying an eyebrow pencil, it is very important that you look through the possible price points associated to help you get a better look into the same.

How to Choose Eyebrow Pencil Color?

If you have naturally sparse eyebrows, chances are that you need the best eyebrow pencil that will help fill it out well without looking too over the top.

1. When it comes round to selecting the eyebrow pencil color, you want to opt for the one that is a shade lighter than what your actual eyebrow hair color is. This ensures that you get a very soft and subtle look to the eyebrow and creates an illusion of the real eyebrow hair.

Types of Eyebrow Pencil

For the most part, eyebrow pencils serve the same purpose, the only difference with them is the kind of design and pigmentation they have.

When it comes round to the types of eyebrow pencil, it isn’t necessarily a lot different; it comes round in different tips-

• Normal pencil shapes
• Angled tip eyebrow pencil
• Fine tip eyebrow pencil

How to Use Eyebrow Pencil?

Every single woman wants snatched eyebrows and for you to get that, you need to do a little bit of hard work.

Depending on the kind of eyebrow hair that you have, you can either fill in the eyebrows or shape and sculpt them from scratch. Irrespective of which category you fall under, it is important that you follow through the steps to get that perfectly shaped brows to complete the overall look that you are going for.

The Steps Involved in it Include:

• Start by outlining the eyebrows wills the pencil, with a light hand
• Once the outline is done, do small strokes much like how you would draw your hair
• Don’t go very heavy handed with the strokes, rather, keep them spaced out and very natural looking
• Once the hair strokes are done, you can fill out wherever there are sparse eyebrows
• The last step is to carve out the eyebrows with a concealer. This is important if you want a snatched and well shaped eyebrow

Finding the best eyebrow pencil can often be a challenge that you have no recollection of. For the most part, it is best suggested to ensure that you do focus on finding the product that suits you best because, at the end of the day, you want the product to work for you and not the other way round. Don’t chase the price point because even the cheapest one can work amazingly and the highest priced one might not.